top of page
Search

The Owners of Island Cow and Mad Hatter Have Opened Two New Eateries in 2024 on Sanibel Island

Writer's picture: Sanibel ExpertSanibel Expert

Sanibel Island has long been known for its stunning beaches, abundant wildlife, and of course, its vibrant food scene. Locals and visitors alike have enjoyed the culinary delights offered by iconic spots such as Island Cow and Mad Hatter. These beloved restaurants have become staples in the community, offering not just delicious meals but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere that reflects the island's charm.

Now, the visionary owners behind these successful establishments are set to expand their culinary empire with the opening of two new eateries. Here’s a sneak peek into what’s on the horizon for Sanibel Island’s dining scene.


A Legacy of Culinary Excellence

Before diving into the exciting new ventures, it’s worth celebrating the legacy that the owners of Island Cow and Mad Hatter have built. Both restaurants have carved out their unique niches on Sanibel Island.

  • Island Cow (under construction 2025) was a family-friendly, casual eatery that has been serving hearty breakfasts, lunches, and dinners for years. Known for its laid-back vibe and extensive menu, it's a go-to spot for both locals and tourists. Whether it’s their famous pancakes or fresh seafood platters, Island Cow consistently delivers a delightful experience.

  • Mad Hatter (Rebuilt TBD), on the other hand, offers a more refined dining experience. Perched on the water's edge, this restaurant is famous for its romantic ambiance and creative, gourmet dishes. It’s the perfect place for special occasions, where guests can enjoy a sunset view along with exquisite cuisine.


The New Ventures

With the success of Island Cow and Mad Hatter, the owners have now introduced two new concepts to the island.

 Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant On Sanibel
1) Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant On Sanibel (Opened 2024)
  1. Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant on Sanibel Island offers a delightful dining experience with a unique blend of charm and elegance. The moment you step in, you're greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements the island's laid-back vibe. The restaurant's interior is tastefully decorated, featuring nautical elements that pay homage to its lighthouse theme, creating a cozy yet sophisticated setting.

    The menu at Wickie’s Lighthouse is impressive, offering a variety of seafood dishes that highlight the freshness of the local catch. The grouper and shrimp dishes are particularly outstanding, cooked to perfection with a blend of flavors that are both bold and delicate. For those who prefer land-based options, the restaurant also offers delicious steaks and chicken dishes that do not disappoint.

    Service at Wickie’s Lighthouse is top-notch. The staff is attentive, knowledgeable, and always ready to provide recommendations or accommodate special requests. The pace of service is just right, allowing you to relax and enjoy your meal without feeling rushed.


One of the highlights of dining at Wickie’s is the outdoor seating area. With views of the water and the iconic Sanibel lighthouse in the distance, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a sunset dinner. The ambiance is enhanced by the gentle sea breeze and the sound of waves, making it a memorable dining experience.


Overall, Wickie’s Lighthouse Restaurant is a must-visit when on Sanibel Island. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner, a family gathering, or just a relaxing meal after a day at the beach, this restaurant delivers on all fronts. The combination of excellent food, attentive service, and a picturesque setting makes it a standout choice.



The Magic Bus on Sanibel
2) The Magic Bus on Sanibel Ice Cream Shop (Opened 2024)

2. The Magic Bus on Sanibel offers you a whimsical treat on Periwinkle Way, The Magic Bus Ice Cream & Caffeine is a must-visit. This spot is an eclectic blend of retro vibes and modern indulgence, offering an array of ice cream flavors and caffeine fixes that are sure to please both kids and adults alike.

The décor is an instant mood-lifter, with its bright, vibrant colors and vintage-inspired theme, evoking a sense of nostalgia. The ambiance feels playful yet relaxed, making it a great place to unwind or enjoy a fun outing with friends or family.

Their ice cream selection is impressive, with unique flavors that go beyond the usual vanilla and chocolate. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cone or something more adventurous, there's something for everyone. The quality is top-notch, with creamy textures and rich flavors that make each bite a delight.

On the caffeine side, the coffee options are equally satisfying. From smooth espressos to frothy lattes, the drinks are crafted with care and pair perfectly with the sweet treats on offer. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, always ready with a recommendation if you're unsure of what to try.


Overall, The Magic Bus Ice Cream & Caffeine is a charming gem in the area, offering a delightful mix of treats and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it's definitely worth stopping by for a taste of their magic.




What to Expect

It’s clear that the owners are committed to maintaining the high standards and unique charm that have made their current restaurants so popular. These new eateries are set to become must-visit destinations on the island, continuing the legacy of excellence that Island Cow and Mad Hatter have established.



Conclusion

The opening of two new eateries by the owners of Island Cow and Mad Hatter is not just exciting news for food lovers but also a testament to the thriving culinary scene on Sanibel Island. Whether you’re a local or planning your next visit, these new additions promise to offer something special. Stay tuned for more updates, and get ready to savor what’s next in Sanibel’s dining evolution.


Please add your comments at page footer to share your thoughts and memories


Are you excited about the new restaurants coming to Sanibel Island? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to follow us for the latest updates on the opening dates, menu previews, and more!


Comentários


bottom of page